Is America The Promise Land For People Of Colour?

usa-flag

When I think about Canada I become numb there are serious social inequities in Canadian society that the media casually ignores important social issues such as institutionalized racism.According to a black professor Joseph Mensah he wrote a book called “Black Canadians“ the racism in Canada is  bubbling ready to explode.

The social constructions of race, class, gender, religion, age, and sexual orientation are left unexamined. Black lesbian feminist Dionne Brand has written a couple of powerful books about Canadian racism “Bread Out of Stone“ and  “A Map To The Door Of No Return“. In these books Brand examines why there is so much hypocrisy in Canada in relation to discussing the issue of race. Race is a taboo word in Canada the Canadian media tends to shy away from discussing race because the ugly truth emerges. Canada is not better then the United States in terms of race relations. Dionne Brand is one of the few black Canadian writers that has the courage to speak out about the racism in Canada and I love her attitude she points out her strong views in her work.

My perspective is in America whites, blacks, Asian Americans, Native Americans, Hispanics have a more open and honesty dialogue about racism.  In Canada there is this “atttiude“ of trying to ignore that racism exists.

The white Canadian press tends to focus on this mythology called multiculturalism which is  such bullshit.  The police chief in Toronto is always a white heterosexual man and the mayor of Toronto is always a white heterosexual person. In the 1990s two white heterosexual women June Rowlands and Barbara Hall managed to become mayor of Toronto but they still followed the status quo.  Wow I think we see a pattern here! It is obvious in Canada when the mythical norm is in control that means everyone else is just supposed to accept it.

I think one of the amazing things about America is the insistence of civil rights activists push for social change even now in the 21st century. In America people realize racism still exists and now toxic and powerful social injustice is against people in relation to class, race, sexual orientation, religion and gender.

In Toronto there are educated immgrants that are taxi car drivers and working in low skilled jobs because they don`t have enough “Canadian experience`according to the racist employers.

What is the federal and provincial governments doing about this social inequality? There is so much hot air up here about social injustice people “say” the right things and nothing changes. There is too much hot air and lip service in the great white north.

Yes America has social problems but in America  a black man can be president and this`s means something!

In Canada we accept whiteness and we don`t even question the status quo. We don`t say anything we remain silent meaning we accept white supremacy.

I remember when I attended York University the vast majority of my professors were white. I also remember a racist white Jewish professor attempted to give me bad grades because I wrote an article about the racism at post secondary institutions.

When I think about President Barack Obama and the inauguration today think America is a place where anything is possible for people of colour. Most of my relatives live in New York City or in New Jersey these areas tend to have a large Jamaican population. The only good thing about Canada is the medical system there is universal health care here meaning it does not matter your class, race, sexual orientation, age, or religion you can access quality health care.

However, in terms of culture Canada is still  basically whitewashed. The hypocrisy about Canada is the fact if people dare to challenge white supremacy or question the power structure in Canada we are told to be “be quiet“ or to “be proud“ to be Canadians. However, let`s get real here in Canada people are a bit pretentious when it relates to race relations.

The supremacy in Canada is more subtle yet also obvious. For example,  on New Years Eve in Quebec on the CBC a recent French Canadian program exposes the issue of Canadian racism. On a French television show called `Bye Bye“ several crude racist comments were broadcast against black people. For instance, on the comedy program one racist joke  compared Barack Obama to a popular black Canadian entertainer Gregory Charles saying they looked the same just because they are black men. In America this nonsense would never take place.

Another racist joke on the French Canadian program on the CBC was the usage of the word “negre“ when translated means “negro“ which is an insult to black people.  The word “negro” would never be broadcast on American television but of course on French Canadian television it was not an issue at all until the black community in Quebec complained to the CRTC.

Thank goodness the blacks in Montreal and Quebec complained to the CRTC.  I never liked Quebec anyway to be honest the racism in Quebec against blacks and other people of colour is so disgusting it makes me want to vomit. I also find the French Canadians to be a bit hypocritical they complain about how English Canada oppresses them yet have no problem promoting racism on the CBC in Quebec. The French Canadians scream and yell about how their French language and culture is being diminished yet they don`t mind discriminating against people of colour.

Have you ever bothered to watch the Canadian television? I swear it is  total bullshit. Have you ever visited the bookstore and wanted to read books on black Canadians or about other people of colour in Canadain history? I guarantee you will find a very small section.

The history of the African American people in the United States is truly incredible they have worked together, created their own colleges and universities. Black Americans have risen from the days of slavery and now a black man and his black wife wil reside in the White House. I never thought this day would come yet this is real. I know a Barack Obama would never exist in Canada for a number of reasons. Although the Canadian media make a big deal about Obama the same Canadian press would never be uplifting if a black man did want to become Prime Minister of Canada. Canadians are more hypocritical and racist then the rest of the world realizes.

My view is black Canadians we aren`t political enough and are a bit apathetic to the covert racism that exists in Canada. The South Asians in Canada are organizing they are getting involved in politics because they understand you can `change` society by getting involved. The South Asian community in Canada are now the largest  visible minority group according to Statistics Canada. Black Canadians we are the third largest visible minority group in Canada.

I think Canada will “change“ when more people speak out about the social injustices taking place against Native Canadians, blacks, women, homosexuals, religious minorities, and about class issues.

The quandary in Canada is that there isn`t enough “fire“ here people are cowards and apathetic to racism. There simply is not “enough“ of a social concern to the detrimental consequences of the institutionalized racism. If we remain silent nothing is going to change. I am proud that south of the border in the United States that social activists of all races realize that people need to keep on fighting for their rights.

Unknown's avatar

About orvillelloyddouglas

I am a gay black Canadian male.

10 responses to “Is America The Promise Land For People Of Colour?”

  1. deedee's avatar
    deedee says :

    I don’t know that its correct to describe either June Rowlands or Barbara Hall as a ‘white, heterosexual man’. Nor would I be so certain of the sexual orientations of all past mayors and police chiefs. That said, I do agree racism is a problem in this fair Dominion. Where I disagree is with the statement that ‘Canada is not better then [sic] the United States in terms of race relations.’ Here, I’m suppose, I side with Austin Clarke more than Dionne Brand.

    Two more corrections, if I may:

    The translation of the French word ‘negre’ is, in fact, ‘negro’. The protest against Bye Bye 2008 spread far beyond the black community.

    In Canada, blacks are not the third largest minority, but the third largest visible minority. Quite a difference.

  2. aulelia's avatar
    aulelia says :

    @Deedee: Yes, you are right. Negre in French means Negro. Noir in French is used for Black as well.

    This is an interesting topic. I think many people obsess over America as a nation having all the answers.

    None of these so-called Western Nations are the promised land for people of colour. The whole concept of a promised land is dystopic because the real answers for black people lie in what we as people want to achieve for ourselves.

    Whether that means living in the West or going back home, we have to want to change and make our own futures.

    No government will do that for us.

  3. orvillelloyddouglas's avatar
    orvillelloyddouglas says :

    I disagree with you Deedee about race relations in Canada being better then the USA I think that’s pure mythology. I agree strongly with Dionne Brand because I think some people are apathetic to the entrenched racism in Canada. In America there is a more honest dialogue about the issue of race. In Canada, I find Canadians to be more pretentious and hypocritical in relation to the deleterious problems of racism.

    Most of the mayors of Toronto were white heterosexual men the mythical norm. Sure June Rowlands and Barbara Hall were mayors of Toronto but they are still white.
    In Quebec according to what I have read “negre” is considered an insult maybe not translated to meaning “nigger” but still an insulting none the less.

    Aulelia I agree that individuals have to help themselves but I would rather live in the USA then say South Africa for example. Yes individuals have to to be independent however in countries such as South Africa the racial and social apartheid still exists in terms of blacks having opportunities to progress. In the United States, yes there is racism but there are more paths to better opportunities for blacks to move up the social ladder. I think that’s my point to have “access” to opportunities that’s lacking in Canada compared to the USA for blacks.

  4. aulelia's avatar
    aulelia says :

    ”Negre” is definitely not supposed to mean the N word, well at least in Martinican French. Frantz Fanon used it a lot in his original works.I am not sure why the Quebecois would use it…

    I don’t really think South Africa is a fair example to use because it is one of the only nations in Africa that has a significant white population.

    Places like Ghana are on the rise and they are over 90% black. Plenty of people there who live middle class lives eat better and live better than middle class people in Europe or America.

    I don’t think the West has the answer for the social problems of black peolpe and I think it is a fallacy to think that.

    I would see nations in the West as more of a platform to improve your destiny as a black person as opposed to the nation shaping your destiny.

  5. deedee's avatar
    deedee says :

    Orville, I’ll be frank here. While I do enjoy your posts, I find that the errors they contain diminish your message. Of course, June Rowlands and Barbara Hall are white, but neither is a “heterosexual man”, as you described all mayors of Toronto (I recognize you’ve removed this claim). The mere fact that Rowlands and Hall were women, following a 150 year parade of men, means that they didn’t follow the status quo. Their elections broke a pattern stretching back to 1834. I’ll add that Hall, who defeated Rowlands (that’s something – two women competing for the office!) has been at the forefront of the battle against racial discrimination. Hall should be applauded, not dismissed as being part of some ‘pattern’.

    Further to this, the use of ‘negre’ may be considered insulting, but it does not mean ‘nigger’. And, of course, ‘minority’ is not the same as ‘visible minority’. As a poet, you surely know the importance of choosing the correct words and getting your facts straight.

  6. orvillelloyddouglas's avatar
    orvillelloyddouglas says :

    If you noticed Deedee I changed the info of the mayor of Toronto tends to be a white heterosexual person and that’s a fact. Yes it’s good that Rowlands and Hall broke the gender barrier in municipal politics in Toronto but they are still white.
    The status quo is that white people are the ones in the power structure while people of colour just “accept” this and I don’t and that’s my perspective.

    Some people of colour in Toronto are cowards they don’t question why does the mayor of Toronto or the police chief always have to be a “white person”? Canadians talk a lot about multiculturism but as far as I am concerned in the political process this isn’t taking place. “Multiculturalism” is pure mythology when the status quo is still “whiteness” at the top of the power structure.

    Since the people of colour population in Toronto is over 50% I think it’s time in the 21st century that a person of colour can become the mayor of Toronto. The pattern is still “whiteness” Hall and Rowlands are still a part of that given the fact they are white. When a person of colour becomes mayor of Toronto that’s when real social change will have taken place.

    The word “negro” is very insulting to blacks and is similar to the word “nigger” because it is obsolete. Now yes obviously the word “nigger” is more explosive but the word “negro” is also offensive.

    I admit I should of used the word “visible minority” but I still think the word “minority” still is within reach of my argument. The word “minority” in my view refers to non whites in Canada because whites are still the majority.

  7. deedee's avatar
    deedee says :

    Orville, I’m pleased that we’ve entered into something of a dialogue. What disturbs me is that Rowlands (of whom I am no fan) and Hall (who raises a cheer) are being dismissed because they are white – no acknowledgment whatsoever that as women their respective elections broke a pattern you once described as ‘always a white heterosexual man’. I ask you, did Barbara Hall not do wonderful things for the city? Are her accomplishments to be dismissed on the basis of the colour of her skin… or due to her sexual orientation? Are you saying that the ‘white heterosexual man’ pattern you perceive will only be broken with the election of a candidate who counters all three descriptors. White, heterosexual, man – these are, after all, not designations one chooses.

    In fact, visible minorities (of which I am one) make up 47 percent of the population of Toronto, not ‘over 50%’ as you claim. I point this out not as a dig, but in reference to my plea to that get your facts straight.

    Let’s make things clear: ‘negro is offensive, of course, but it has nothing near the power of the word ‘nigger’. Would you not agree?

    Yes, let’s have a person of colour run for mayor of Toronto – but not because they are a person or colour, but because they have something great to contribute. And let’s not fall into the trap of dismissing all white heterosexual men for the simple reason that they are white heterosexual men.

  8. redapple's avatar
    redapple says :

    omg.i’m so glad you did this post. in my american history class, we recently were asked to form groups and discuss a few Questions(about racism). so anyway, i got discussing with a few people and when it was time to discuss the 2nd question, which was CAN YOU SPECIFY ANY SPECIFIC PROBLEMS RELATED TO RACISM TODAY-IN THE U.S. OR CANADA? . the other people in the group didn’t say anything about racism in canada. i instead put in my 2 cents saying exactly what you said. i said that in canada, people occupying the “high positions ” are mostly white if not all. i further elaborated by saying that i don’t see any black politician/leader to which another person replied ‘but there are hardly any black people in canada’. so anyway, the reason i’m writing is to ask if you have any idea what the population of black people in canada. and what is the difference between visible minority and minority group? is it the fact that aboriginal people are excluded when talking about visible minorities and not when talking about a minority group? help!

  9. orvillelloyddouglas's avatar
    orvillelloyddouglas says :

    Deedee are you black? I have to ask this question because the word “negro” is just as offensive as the word “nigger”. The word “negro” is an ancient term that needs to be destroyed. It was very racist and offensive for the CBC to allow this racist language to be used against black folks.

    My perspective redapple is that Canadians are more hypocritical when discussing the issue of racism. Racism definitely exists in Canada the subject of race is considered “taboo” unlike the United States. In America I believe Americans are more open about discussing the issue of racism. I also believe African Americans are much more vocal and organized in dealing with race relations then black Canadians.

    However, in Canada people here tend to be more reticent about discussing racism. It’s like if people don’t talk about race they act like racism doesn’t exist. In the western provinces for example the Aboriginal population encounter a lot of racism. The racism in Canada is more like talking behind someone’s back. I prefer the American way at least then I know where I stand.

    Redapple there are blacks in Canada according to Statistics Canada black Canadians are the third largest visible minority group. Blacks have been living in Canada since the 1600s. According to the 2006 Canadian census there are about 783,795 blacks living in Canada they tend to be from Africa or the Caribbean. There are also black Canadians that are ancestors of African American slaves that live in the province of Nova Scotia.

  10. deedee's avatar
    deedee says :

    Orville, to answer your question: Yes, I am black.

    You may feel that “‘negro’ is just as offensive as the word ‘nigger'”, but I do not. Allow me to elaborate. The word “negro” is a word that has fallen into disfavour. Where once we used the word, we now prefer “black” or “African-“. Its use today MAY be considered a slur, but this was not always the case. “Nigger”, on the other hand, was never anything but a hurtful and offensive term.

    So, do we now consider the United Negro College Fund to have a racist name?

    Was Martin Luther King being offensive when he used the word “negro” (no less than sixteen times!) in his “I Have a Dream” speech?

    I think not.

Leave a comment